An ambition frustrated: country houses never completed

The delight of a country house is the beautiful meeting of house, setting and contents to create a complete picture.  Yet, for some houses, they never make that stage – finances or death of the instigator usually being the main obstacle to completion.  For some, these half-built aspirations are demolished, others left as a shell which can tantalise us today as to why they failed to achieve their purpose.

In previous generations, the simplicity of construction methods would necessarily mean that in some cases a decade could pass from plans being drawn up to actually moving in. As now, families can go from great wealth to poverty in a short time so to build a substantial country house was a commitment and a statement of the aspirations of the owners as to their future good fortune and health – though sometimes it was not to be.

Many a mansion has been started with grand ambitions which will forever remain unfulfilled (how impressive would Goodwood House in Sussex be if they’d completed the other five sides of the intended octogon?).  However this post is focussed on those which were started and ended only as frustrated shells.

Woodchester Mansion, Gloucestershire (Image: Matthew Lister via Wikipedia)

Woodchester Mansion, Gloucestershire (Image: Matthew Lister via Wikipedia)

One of the most impressive of these is Woodchester Mansion in Gloucestershire.  Originally built for William Leigh, a wealthy trader, who, inspired by his conversion to Catholicism, sought to create a religious community in the Cotswolds on his estate.  As any good Catholic was inclined to do at the time, he consulted A.W. Pugin, a devout Catholic who believed that Gothic architecture was the only true Christian style.  He produced plans for a grand new house (after naturally condemning the existing house as “…a more hopeless case of repairs I never saw.“) and a church and monastery, and sent his new design for the house with his estimate of £7,118.  Anyone familiar with Pugin’s career will know that he never saw an estimate he couldn’t exceed so Leigh probably had a lucky escape when Pugin resigned the commission in 1846.  Leigh instead turned to another Catholic architect Charles Hansom (b.1817 – d.1888).  Leigh’s religious zeal took priority so the church was completed in 1849 and the monastery in 1853 after which work started on the new house.

However, progress was slow; the workers were occasionally given tasks elsewhere on the estate, funds were inadequate, and Leigh was also a perfectionist who took a close interest which can only have delayed things.  The architect had also changed, with the young and inexperienced Benjamin Bucknall taking over and revising the designs to a combination of Pugin and the French architect Viollet-le-Duc, giving the house a distinctly French influence.  However, Leigh’s declining health overtook the build and he died in 1873 with only the shell complete.  A profligate son, declining family fortunes, the World Wars, and its isolation meant that despite various plans, including completion for use as mental hospital offices, it simply sat in its parkland. Now grade-I listed, the house gives a unique insight into the construction methods of the time.

Worksop Manor, Nottinghamshire (Image: Heritage Images)

Worksop Manor, Nottinghamshire (Image: Heritage Images)

Perhaps the grandest house never to be completed was the Worksop Manor in Nottinghamshire for the Dukes of Norfolk.  Part of the ‘Dukeries‘, that area of the county formerly rich in ducal seats, the original 500-room Elizabethan Worksop Manor, designed by Robert Smythson, burnt down in 1761 during renovations, destroying £100,000 (approx. £143m) of works of art from the famous Arundel collection.  Although childless, the 9th Duke decided to rebuild for the benefit of his eventual heir.

The plans were colossal and would have been the largest house in the county and maybe the country – if it had been completed.  Even Horace Walpole, who had developed a discerning eye for country houses during his many tours, thought the Duke’s schemes “…so vast and expensive that it is scarcely possible they can be completed.“. Designed by James Paine (b.1717 – d.1789), the aim was to mark the status and learning of the Duke’s family, building only one side, however it alone was 23-bays, 318ft long and featured a fine Corinthian column supported by six columns, with a 37ft x 25ft entrance hall, decorated by Flemish artist Theodore de Bruyn, and a grand drawing room of 50ft x 30ft.

However, following the death of the heir, Edward Howard, the grief-stricken Norfolks abandoned the project and concentrated on their Sussex seat Arundel Castle.  The 10th and 11th Dukes never completed it so it was therefore unsurprising that the 12th Duke decided to sell the house and estate in 1838 to the neighbouring Duke of Newcastle-under-Lyme for £375,000.  With his own palatial house at the nearby Clumber House, the Duke was not interested in the house, just in adding the land to his own. Rather than pay for the upkeep, the Duke sold the fabric of the building before demolishing the rest in June 1841 leaving just the stables and part of the service wing.  It was these that were later restored to make a rather awkward looking new Worksop Manor.

Lyvden New Bield, Northamptonshire (Image: Ed Bramley via Wikipedia)

Lyveden New Bield, Northamptonshire (Image: Ed Bramley via Wikipedia)

Altogether more mysterious is Lyveden New Beild in Northamptonshire.  Built for the remarkable if oft persecuted Catholic Sir Thomas Tresham (b.? – d.1605), a well-educated and wealthy man who moved in the highest social circles.  Never intended as a main residence (Lyveden Old Bield), this was apparently a summer house, a retreat for the owner during the annual spring clean of his main house.  That said, this is a house with many meanings.  Designed by Robert Stickells (b.? – d.1620) to indulge Tresham’s interest in antiquity and religious symbolism, the house was built in the shape of a cross and other elements aligned or organised according to mystical numbers, often alluding to the Holy Trinity.  Tresham also used the same ideas in his construction of the famous Rushton Triangular Lodge, a small folly also on the estate.

However, the same ardent Catholicism which drove the design of the New Bield and the Lodge also meant that he was regularly persecuted for his faith, frequently being fined huge amounts.  With borrowing his only option, funds were scarce and his estate heavily indebted.  Perhaps surprisingly, this half-finished house, set in fine gardens and parkland, was never bought and completed and so remains an architectural enigma to this day.


Visiting

Woodchester Mansion holds regular open days more details available on their website. The surrounding Park is owned by the National Trust.

Worksop Manor is still very much a private residence and is not open to the public.

Lyveden New Beild is owned by the National Trust and is regularly open.

Advertisements

About Matthew Beckett - The Country Seat

An amateur architectural historian with a particular love of UK country houses in all their many varied and beautiful forms.
This entry was posted in News and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to An ambition frustrated: country houses never completed

  1. Jeff says:

    Given the cost of new build masonry and loss of the crafts, it would be interesting to know which houses, during the last century, have been completed. There is clearly no substitute for the patina of some of these old shells and it is difficult to imagine that no one has taken advantage of the existence of these “magnificent starting points.”

  2. Andrew says:

    Jeff, it is indeed rare for a house to be substantially built, but left unfinished and never lived in, and remain today, as most were completed by either the next generation of the family, or a new owner, or demolished and the remains sold or reused, so Woodchester Mansion and Lyveden New Bield are quite unique, being protected and preserved in their current condition. A potential contemporary example is Hamilton Palace (formerly called High Cross House) in Sussex, started in 2000 by Nicholas van Hoogstraten and abandoned before he went to jail, which has been discussed in a recent post. Worksop Manor is different from these cases because even though only over a quarter of the planned house was completed, it was lived in immediately, and thereafter periodically by the family during its 80-year existence, before being demolished in 1843 by its new owner. Another house possibly never lived in was Witham Park at Witham Friary in Somerset, built for William Beckford to the designs of Robert Adam from 1762, which appears to have never been completed, because it was demolished in the 1790s. In Ireland there is also the ruined Jigginstown Castle (aka Sigginstown House) in County Kildare, built from 1632 for the 1st Earl of Strafford, which was never finished. Going back further in history, there is the uncompleted Kirby Muxloe Castle in Leicestershire, built 1480-3 by William Hastings until he was executed.

    In addition to Goodwood House, Kedleston Hall in Derbyshire would also have been even more magnificent if its other 2 wings had been completed as planned, such as was done at Holkham Hall in Norfolk with its 4 wings.

  3. Jeff says:

    Thank you for this valuable additional information. I was particularly interested in the insight into unexecuted plans for Holkham and Kedleston, both of which I have visited. As always, I am looking forward to your next post. I am hoping to ferret out what may be an exciting future for Lutyens’ Heathcote in York. Any thoughts?

  4. Andrew says:

    Thanks, Jeff, although I should clarify my last post and say that the Holkham Hall plans were fully executed. Regarding Heathcote, which is technically a town villa rather than a country house, although it does have the feel of a small stately home and the association through Lutyens designing about 15 country houses and altering over 15 more, I gather you are referring to Heathcote being under offer since mid-November, with the preferred buyer (probably for a private home) about to complete the deal for about £2.6m:
    http://www.ilkleygazette.co.uk/news/news_local/8690813.Several_bids_for_Lutyens_mansion

  5. Jeff says:

    Andrew; Thanks for the link. I do hope that the buyer will return this magnificent villa to its intended use. The thought of this magnificent home housing a family is indeed heartening! The Lutyens book by A.S.G. Butler contains remarkable photos of the interior……..particularly beautiful is the apse under the main staircase. Once again, thank you for sharing through this fascinating blog and please keep up the great work!

  6. Andrew says:

    Jeff, is the staircase hall apse photo that you referred to (I assume from a reprint of the 1950 book “The Architecture of Sir Edwin Lutyens” Volume 1 – Country Houses) similar to Country Life photo number 840145 below (taken in 1910)?
    http://www.countrylifeimages.co.uk/Search.aspx?s=Heathcote

    • Jeff says:

      Exactly, photo 84015. I think it is a marvelous composition. The juxtaposition of the arches below and the linearity of the staircase elements above complements the mystery of the doorways below and is amazing…… vintage Lutyens. They simply don’t design like this any more. I guess it is too expensive to incorporate such detail and complexity in a relatively “unimportant” part of the house. For me, this is the real magic of interior architecture.

  7. A great shame to see so many houses were never finished but on the positive side we are seeing more being renovated for short-term lets. Hopefully others will follow suit and country houses can once again be filled for parties! .

  8. Stephen says:

    Another incomplete house on the market at £16,666.67 per room. Although, I suspect that it will cost a lot more than that to put each right. I don’t know if they are throwing in all the cars but there must be some worth doing up as well as the house.

    • Stephen says:

      Another picture.

    • Stephen says:

      Location on Google.

    • countryhouses says:

      Hi Stephen

      Blackborough is a fantastic house and should never have been allowed to get into such a state – but it was technically completed and lived in. Apparently during WWII, troops billeted there would amuse themselves by driving a jeep up and down the staircase. It was built for the Earl of Egremont who had it designed as effectively two houses arranged around a central courtyard – he was to live in the front half and the local rector in the back half. However, he had bigger plans and started – though never completed – Silverton Park just outside Exeter (demolished c.1900).

      Apparently it would be worth the purchaser taking the cars as there are supposed to be a couple of decent ones amongst the hundreds of bits of junk. I dread to think what the cost of clearing up such an environment would be but I fear it may put off many a buyer.

      Matt

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s