Despite objections, Forty Hall renovation to proceed as planned

Forty Hall, Enfield (Image: Enfield Independent)

Despite objections from the Victorian Society, the plans for the extensive works at Forty Hall planned and then self-approved by Enfield Council will start later this year.  As reported earlier (‘Forty Hall ‘renovation’ gets approval from council but probably not from everyone else‘) the council proposed to make some significant alterations to the Grade-I listed house which seem to threaten the interiors but the latest story gives a very rosy view of the plans.

It seems that little has been changed from the original plans and the council will proceed with the plans despite the various concerns about the proposals.   Official bodies have a long history of believing themselves to be right despite credible evidence to the contrary so this determined attitude is not unsurprising.  It does seem a shame that heritage protection has now been superseded by a belief that the ends justify the means – with one of the most used phrases being that the changes will promote ‘community access’.  However, any plans should always bear in mind that the house is not simply a resource to be used but a vital part of local heritage which is not simply for this generation to (mis-)use as they might see fit.  It will be interesting to see whether the council can deliver an architecturally sensitive project or whether the warnings and concerns of others will be proved valid.

More details: ‘Enfield’s crown jewel, Forty Hall, to be restored from next year‘ [This is Local London]

One thought on “Despite objections, Forty Hall renovation to proceed as planned

  1. Dale September 1, 2010 / 08:22

    Local authorities cannot give themselves listed building consent for buildings they own.They must apply to the local government office which supervises them, in London, the Government Office for London. I believe applications are then scrutinised by English Heritage before the Government Office then grants consent. And that’s for Grade II listed buildings. Applications for Grade II* and Grade I listed buildings have to be looked at by EH, although they may pass the approvals process back to the LPA thereafter.
    You don’t say what EH’s position on this case was. But the works proposed don’t sound very SPAB-friendly, seemingly involving lots of irreversible work removing later alterations and ‘restoring’ the building to its previous incarnation as a Jacobean house. Presumably the VicSoc’s objection was on the grounds of the removal of its Victorian features?

Leave a Reply to Dale Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.